We are now open rain or shine and look forward to a great season!


Get ready to experience waterfront dining at its finest! Now taking reservations on OpenTable.



Join us to explore our updated menu and enjoy the stylish ambiance of our bar and rooftop observation deck.


Welcome to Nicky’s

Visit our indoor or outdoor, waterfront casual dining rooms for a great lunch, dinner, and cocktails. Hang out at our friendly bar and enjoy a delicious cocktail or one of our extensive selection of beers. You’ll be surrounded by one of the most beautiful water views of the Great South Bay and Bay Shore Marina. It’s like being on vacation when visiting Nicky’s – it’s the perfect place to stop by before or after your day on the bay. For a perfect end to a perfect day enjoy our famous sunset view!

Pull your boat up to Nicky’s and fill up on some gas, too! We have added even more boat docking with a 100′ floating dock for our dock and dine service.  Our friendly attendants will have you on your way in no time. Whether you captain a Hatteras Sport Fisherman or a 17 foot Mako, our gas dock will fill all your needs.