Welcome to Nicky's on the Bay
at Bay Shore Marina
We are closed fo the season. We look forward to seeing you in 2024.
Now Accepting Reservations
Get ready to experience waterfront dining at its finest!
Explore out new menu which has been refined with the finest ingredients available and enjoy the views and a cocktail from our rooftop observation deck.
Experience the charm of waterfront dining at Nicky’s, where our indoor and outdoor casual dining spaces are the perfect setting for an enjoyable lunch, dinner, or cocktails. Our welcoming bar invites you to relax and savor our expertly crafted cocktails or choose from an extensive selection of beers.
Nestled along the Great South Bay and Bay Shore Marina, Nicky’s offers some of the most picturesque water views you can find. It’s akin to a mini vacation each time you visit us – a delightful stopover before or after your adventures on the bay.
As the perfect day draws to a close, allow us to enchant you with our renowned sunset view – it truly is the cherry on top of your Nicky’s experience! We look forward to welcoming you to our little slice of paradise.
Pull your boat up to Nicky’s and fill up on some gas, too! We have added even more boat docking with a 100′ floating dock for our dock and dine service. Our friendly attendants will have you on your way in no time. Whether you captain a Hatteras Sport Fisherman or a 17 foot Mako, our gas dock will fill all your needs.